In stock
Sold out

Mystery Box


You Save: $25.01 (51%)

Shopify Secure
AES 256bit
Discover Network
American Express

Inside this box is at least $50 in art supplies, stationery, pens, pencils, paper, paints, and whatever else we found in our wondrous, somewhat disorganized stockroom. We've offered Mystery Boxes before, but these might be the best ones yet. For this limited run of Fall 2020 boxes, we've included some excellent products from brands that don't allow retailers to advertise a discount. We can't name them, but we can pack them in these half-price boxes and surprise you with an amazing deal.

We can tell you a few types of things you might receive in this edition of the Mystery Box: artist grade watercolor brushes, various markers and pens, art pads, and high-end notebooks. We are making room for new items in these categories, so we're letting go of some really good stuff this time around.

A few notes on our Mystery Box promo:

  • We will ship these out while supplies last. In the past, they have sold out really quickly, so if you want one, now's the time.
  • Unlike last time, we are allowing Mystery Boxes to be part of free shipping orders. Keep in mind that if we do pack your Mystery Box with other items, it may be in alternate packaging rather than our usual shipping boxes.
  • Mystery Boxes vary in size, shape, and contents. We guarantee the retail prices of the contents to be $50 or more, but other than that, we make no promises about your box. There are no returns or exchanges on these heavily discounted boxes.

Good luck! Here's hoping you get a box that absolutely delights you.



We ship all orders from our store in St. Louis, Missouri. 95% of orders are processed in 1-2 business days (Wednesday through Sunday). Shipping to the United States is always free for orders over $59. For orders under $59, domestic shipping rates start at $3.50. You can calculate your shipping cost in the cart or at checkout. For St. Louis residents, we also offer free curbside pickup. Just select "Pick Up" on the first page of checkout.


If there's a problem with your order, please contact our customer service team at If your order is damaged or defective, we will send you a prepaid return label and replace the item immediately. If you change your mind about an order, you can ship it back to us in new condition for a refund or exchange. However, if there is no error on our part, we cannot refund shipping charges or pay for return shipping. The deadline for all returns is 30 days from the delivery date. All clearance items, including our famous Mystery Box, are final sale.


We are an independent retailer trusted by artists since 2015, and our expert staff are happy to help you with any questions you might have about our products and services. We love helping our customers choose colors, build gift packages for friends, and get started with new tools and materials. We can also take special orders for items not listed on this site.


(314) 884-8345
9 AM to 5 PM Central Time,
Wednesday through Sunday

Mystery Box

Mystery Box